English
reviewers have commented positively about Azumanga Daioh. In Manga: The
Complete Guide, Jason Thompson refers to it as a "charming comedy" and a
"quiet master of the four-panel form", praising the series comedic
timing and use of running gags. He felt one of the series' best points
was its "character-driven writing", but does warn that its moe nature
and the jokes that revolve around the "vaguely pedophilic teacher" might
disturb some newer readers of manga.[68] He later said that Azumanga
Daioh was an "almost totally innocent" kind of moe, centered around
"peep[ing] at the chaste world of girls", in which "adorable girls do
adorable things". Cosplay Costumes The French manga dictionary Dicomanga noted that
despite being a moe series targeted at otaku, it also appealed to female
readers for celebrating "friendships between girls as well as [its]
comedy."[70] Marc Hairston describes Azumanga Daioh as being "slightly
disjointed", with "frequently oblique" and "culturally biased" humour,
and says it is both "lighter" and "more wry" than Maria-sama ga Miteru.
He describes the characters of Azumanga as being "individuals with
slightly offbeat personalities".[71] Mark Thomas, writing for Mania.com,
says that each character has "a defining personality trait that is
ramped up to abnormal levels" and that each has a foil, which highlights
these traits and prevents them from becoming too annoying or
unbelievable as characters. Thomas said that the yonkoma format does not
lend itself to "complex story arcs", and the story is presented as
"quick snapshots of random moments in their daily routines", noting that
the narrative is character-driven.[72] Patrick King, writing for Anime
Fringe, considered it to be "one of the funniest, most adorable manga
series I've read".[73] IGN noted the lack of background art, but said
that the expressive faces of the characters made up for it.
Fred
Patton of Animation World Magazine described the anime as "delightfully
witty and even an educational window onto what Japanese high school life
is really like."[74] Chris Beveridge of Anime on DVD, stated that
"There's a lot to laugh with here and a cast of characters that grow
quickly on you as you start finding those you favor and those you
don't."[75] Andrew Shelton from Anime Meta explains that "The character
of the girls is extremely well brought out. The superb observation, Azumanga Daioh Costumes and
ability to capture expression, makes the anime incredibly fun to watch
in addition to meeting the story requirements. The action, and very rich
comedy, are also wonderfully represented. There is just so much
meaning, and charm, in even the most minor of expressions."[76] The
reviewers of THEM Anime and Anime News Network felt that fans who had
already graduated high school would feel nostalgic at times while
watching Azumanga Daioh.
No comments:
Post a Comment